Is Classic Firearms Legit?

Last Updated : November 13, 2025 80 view(s)

Classic Firearms (formerly known as Classic Arms) is a long-standing retailer in the firearms industry, especially popular for surplus weapons and ammo deals.

If you’re wondering “Is Classic Firearms a legit company?” or “Is Classic Firearms reputable?”, this article will dive into the facts: the company’s history, customer reviews, and trust indicators like the BBB.

Spoiler: Yes, Classic Firearms is a legitimate retailer with decades of history, though like any business it has its pros and cons.

Company History and Background

Classic Firearms has a pedigree dating back to the 1980s. Many seasoned shooters recall that Classic Arms (its original name) was a go-to source for military surplus rifles and gear long before e-commerce took off.

Over the years, it rebranded as Classic Firearms and expanded into a comprehensive online store offering not just surplus items but also modern firearms, ammunition, and accessories. The company is based in Monroe, North Carolina, and has been in business for decades, a fact that strongly indicates it’s not a fly-by-night scam.

Classic Firearms’ longevity in the industry (it has “decades in the business”) is a big trust factor.

A fraudulent operation wouldn’t last that long. Furthermore, Classic Firearms has embraced online retail and built a large customer base through its website and even a YouTube channel, where they engage with the firearms community (e.g., announcing giveaways, new products, etc).

This visible, interactive presence is something only a real, legitimate company would maintain.

Customer Reviews and Reputation

So, is Classic Firearms “good” to buy from? Customer experiences seem generally positive, with a few caveats:

Better Business Bureau

Classic Firearms holds an A+ rating with the BBB and is an Accredited Business. This means Classic Firearms meets the BBB’s standards for honesty and routinely resolves customer complaints.
According to the BBB, Classic Firearms has 20 total complaints in the last 3 years, which is a relatively modest number for an online retailer of its size. Those complaints range from product issues to the occasional service problem, but importantly, Classic has addressed them (hence the A+ rating).
The BBB accreditation and A+ score are strong indicators that Classic Firearms is a legit, responsible company. They’ve been accredited since 2015, demonstrating a commitment to customer service over time.

Customer Reviews

Classic Firearms doesn’t have a huge presence on Trustpilot (as of this writing, Trustpilot shows a middling ~2-star rating, but based on a small number of reviews). However, on other platforms like Reviews.io and SiteJabber, Classic Firearms scores quite well, often around 4.5 to 4.8 out of 5 from thousands of buyers.
This suggests that the vast majority of customers are satisfied with their purchases, citing good deals on ammo and guns, and products arriving as described. Some users have reported slow shipping or inventory mix-ups during periods of heavy demand, but those instances are not the norm.
On balance, Classic Firearms has a positive reputation for delivering what it promises.

Community Feedback

In firearm enthusiast forums, Classic Firearms is generally regarded as a reputable source, especially for surplus firearms and hard-to-find ammunition.
Some longtime customers note that the company had some “growing pains” in the past, for example, delays when demand spiked, but that they have improved and usually communicate transparently about any delays.
Classic’s active social media and YouTube presence also help keep customers informed and engaged, which is a sign of a company caring about its reputation.

Trust Signals and Policies

A few more factors that underscore Classic Firearms’ legitimacy:

A+ BBB = Commitment to Ethics

The A+ BBB rating isn’t easy to maintain. Classic Firearms earning that implies they respond to complaints promptly and honor their policies.
The BBB profile even mentions that accreditation means they’re committed to resolving issues and operating ethically, giving new buyers peace of mind.

Secure Website and Processes

Classic’s website is secured (HTTPS) and they use standard payment processors, you’re not asked to do anything sketchy like pay via wire transfer to a random account, which is something scam sites might do.
They also require FFL (Federal Firearms License) info for gun purchases, as legally mandated, demonstrating they follow regulations.

Return Policy and Customer Care

While ammunition sales are typically final (as with most retailers), Classic Firearms has customer-friendly policies for other products. They also have a customer support line.
People have reported that if an order issue arises, Classic works to fix it.
One BBB review even shows a customer initially had an issue but then “Classic Firearms was very supportive and I highly recommend them” after resolving it. That kind of turnaround is a hallmark of a legit business that cares about its customers.

Conclusion: Classic Firearms Is Legitimate

There’s no doubt that Classic Firearms is a legitimate and reputable company in the firearms retail space. With a decades-long history, an A+ BBB rating, and a large base of satisfied customers, Classic Firearms has proven itself trustworthy.

It’s not a scam, when you place an order, you’re dealing with a real company that will ship your product as advertised. That said, like any retailer, Classic Firearms isn’t perfect. High demand can sometimes lead to slower shipping, and inventory on surplus items can be hit or miss. But those are normal business challenges, not red flags of illegitimacy.

The overwhelming evidence, from customer reviews to BBB accreditation, shows Classic Firearms is a safe place to buy guns and ammo. They have survived and grown in a competitive industry by being honest and delivering value.

So if you’re asking “Is Classic Firearms legit or a scam?”, you can confidently conclude that Classic Firearms is legit and trustworthy as your ammo and firearms supplier.